Interregional Travel in California: Assessment, Analysis, and Implications for Emissions

Status

Complete

Project Timeline

June 1, 2015 - April 30, 2017

Principal Investigator

Project Team

Department(s)

Civil and Environmental Engineering

Project Summary

In 2008, California passed the Sustainable Communities and Climate Protection Act of
2008 (Sustainable Communities Act, or SB375) that set regional targets for greenhouse
gas (GHG) emission reductions from passenger vehicle use. California’s Metropolitan
Planning Organizations (MPOs) are currently in the process of developing Sustainable
Communities Strategies (SCS), as part of their Regional Transportation Plans (RTP),
outlining strategies to meet greenhouse gas reduction targets adopted by the Air
Resources Board (ARB) in 2010.
MPOs use regional travel forecasting models to estimate vehicle trips (VT), average
speeds, and vehicle miles traveled (VMT), which serve in turn as input to regional
emissions models to estimate the GHG emissions. The state of the practice in regional
modeling, however, may limit the potential effectiveness of forecasting models to
accurately estimate interregional travel and the associated GHG impacts. There is but
limited empirical data on the proportion of interregional travel (measured by vehicle trips
and/or vehicle miles traveled), in part due to the definition of regional boundaries and
consistencies in external traffic counts at these boundaries. A rule of thumb is building
regional travel forecasting models is to have no more than 15 percent of total travel
crossing the regional cordon line. Even with this rule, proper estimation of interregional
travel may have a significant impact in overall estimates of GHG emissions.
A study is proposed to assess the state-of-the-practice in forecasting interregional travel
in California, to consider alternate methods to better represent interregional travel, and
to make recommendations on data needs and modeling policy.

Transit Investment Impacts on Land Use Beyond the Half-Mile Mark

Status

Complete

Project Timeline

January 1, 2017 - December 31, 2017

Principal Investigator

Project Summary

Problem Statement: While transit-oriented development (TOD) and other transit-centered initiatives have emerged in recent years as core strategies for attaining the vision of the SB 375, little is known about how our investment in a public transit system can actually modify urban land use patterns, and under what circumstances the (favorable) effects occur, and to what (spatiotemporal) extent.  Prior research, although valuable, tends to assume transit lines/stations as a homogeneous facility/amenity without explicit consideration of their history, service quality, and other attributes that could generate a significant difference in land use outcomes.  Furthermore, little scholarly attention has been paid to the expansion (or quality improvements) of a transit system that can (re)shape land use patterns consistently over time.  In practice, half-mile circles have been used widely in delineating transit corridor areas.  What can be achieved beyond the half-mile walking distance radius boundaries has remained unanswered.
Proposal: Building on a recently completed project, “Infill Dynamics in Rail Transit Corridors: Challenges and Prospects for Integrating Transportation and Land Use Planning”, this project will assess the impacts of light rail transit expansion on broader vicinity areas in Southern California.  The project aims to better understand the mechanisms between transit characteristics and land (re)development dynamics and the potential land use change which could be associated with Southern California’s regional transportation and sustainability plan which calls for increased density in high-quality transit areas.  
Specifically, this research will solidify an understanding of the detailed mechanisms driving urban land use change near transit investments and will extend the ability to translate results from models into policy recommendations by:
1. Analyzing the potential impacts of light rail investments on areas beyond the traditional half-mile station radius and associated evolution of land use patterns and property markets in transit corridors;
2. Examining the influence of policy context variables on land use dynamics in transit corridors, including the influence of planning tools intended to promote near-transit development;
3. Conducting comparative case studies on the planning and development context of major developments in transit corridors to extend quantitative model findings with qualitative insights into the role of planning institutions and developers on near-transit development.
Expected Impact and Benefits: The proposed project will greatly advance the understanding of urban land use change dynamics under the influence of transit system development/expansion.  As noted above, little is known about (potential) changes that can take place beyond the half-mile circles.  Results will shed light on the effectiveness of transit investment in creating a more sustainable urban/metropolitan spatial structure and therefore inform local, regional, and state agencies.  In addition, by analyzing the influence of policy and context variables, this research will provide insight into how local actions and institutional structures can play a significant role in shaping land use and transportation dynamics of urban areas.  The research’s emphasis on broader transit vicinities will also help planners think beyond the traditional half-mile circles and refine their strategies for directing growth into high-quality transit areas.  This will eventually contribute to a more complete realization of urban development that is environmentally and socio-economically sustainable.

Policy and Literature Review on the Effect Millennials Have on Vehicle Miles Traveled, Greenhouse Gas Emissions, and the Built Environment

Status

Complete

Project Timeline

January 1, 2017 - December 31, 2017

Principal Investigator

Project Team

Department(s)

Urban Planning and Public Policy

Project Summary

The driving habits of US millennials (roughly defined as persons born between 1980-2000, with a current estimated population of 75 million) has been identified as having a dampening effect on automobile ownership and passenger vehicle miles travelled (VMT).  There is little available information or research to enable a quantification of this effect, and its potential magnitude in future decades.  Metropolitan Planning Organizations (MPO) need more information to be able to model or otherwise estimate the impact of this effect on regional VMT and greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions, for purposes of their Sustainable Communities Strategies (SCS) under SB 375.
This research will investigate the magnitude of potential GHG and VMT benefits from millennial driving behavior and develop data and information that MPOs can use to estimate the regional GHG and VMT benefits of this demographic shift for purposes of meeting SB 375 targets. The research will involve 4 tasks:  
1. A review of existing research and available data sources on the effects of millennial driving behavior on VMT; 
2. A discussion of the possible causes of millennial driving behavior and how the built environment may affect this behavior;
3. An estimate of the magnitude of the effect of millennial driving behavior on VMT and GHG emissions; 
4. An identification of the kinds of regional policy interventions or SCS strategies that would be effective in encouraging a continuation of this behavior even as millennials age.

Do Compact, Accessible, and Walkable Communities Promote Gender Equality?

Status

Complete

Project Timeline

January 1, 2017 - December 31, 2017

Principal Investigator

Department(s)

Urban Planning and Public Policy

Project Summary

GPS-based activity and travel diary surveys have been increasingly used to assess whether transportation and sustainability strategies for compact, mixed-use, and transit accessible communities result in reduced vehicle travel, reduced greenhouse gas emissions, greater opportunities for physical activity, and enhanced accessibility. For instance, the Southern California’s long range plan indicates over 50% of new jobs and housing will be located in high-quality transit corridors, and the Los Angeles Metropolitan Transportation Authority (LA Metro) is currently aggressively expanding its rail transit network, but few studies have examined the impacts of such investments on travel and spatial activity patterns.
This study provides insights into the impact of rail transit investments and compact development policies. This component examines California Household Travel Survey (CHTS) data to examine whether more compact, mixed-use and transit accessible areas are associated with greater gender equality in the geographic extent of activity-travel patterns given previous research that suggests compact design may help reduce gender differences in the division of household tasks including errands and “chauffeuring travel”.  

An Analysis of Travel Characteristics of Carless Households in California

Status

Complete

Project Timeline

January 1, 2017 - December 31, 2017

Principal Investigator

Project Team

Department(s)

Civil and Environmental Engineering

Project Summary

Problem Statement: Compared to mobile households, mobility-impaired households are at a disadvantage for accessing employment, educational, social, and recreational opportunities. Currently, around 10.5 million US households do not own cars (according to American Community Survey data); in California, approximately 8% of households do not have cars. These households, which are often neglected in transportation policy discussions, can be organized into two groups: “involuntary” and “voluntary”. Understanding the travel behavior of households that voluntarily decided to forgo cars is important for informing policies that aim to reduce dependency on cars and greenhouse gas emissions. Understanding the travel pattern of involuntary carless households is no less important as these households are at greater risk of physical isolation, poor access, and social exclusion. Unfortunately, knowledge of travel behavior of carless households is lacking. 
Proposal: This research will shed some light on the travel behavior of voluntary and involuntary carless households in California by analyzing data from the 2012 California Household Travel Survey (CHTS). Researchers will analyze both travel diaries and GPS data to characterize the trip patterns of voluntary and involuntary carless households and contrast their trips with those of households with vehicles. Researchers will then estimate mode choice and create generalized Structural Equation Models (GSEM) to assess the effects of various socioeconomic and built environment variables on travel behavior.
Expected Impact and Benefits: This research will be of interest to transit and planning agencies throughout California, and to public and private organizations fighting poverty and social exclusion. The results of this research will provide a better understanding of how to reduce the dependence on motor vehicles by examining households who are voluntarily carless. It will also inform policies designed to help poor households who are mobility impaired.

Transportation Plans: Their Informational Content and Use Patterns in Southern California

Status

Complete

Project Timeline

January 1, 2018 - December 31, 2018

Principal Investigator

Department(s)

Urban Planning and Public Policy

Project Summary

Since 1937, “all cities and counties [have been] required to adopt master plans [called ‘general plans’ nowadays] … [and, in 1955] land use and circulation elements [became] required in the general plan” (California Governor’s Office of Planning and Research, 2003). Recently, as the California Complete Streets Act (AB 1358) is implemented, “all cities and counties, upon the next update of their circulation element, must plan for the development of multimodal transportation networks.” Other state legislation (e.g., SB 375) has placed emphasis on internal consistency (e.g., consistency of a locality’s circulation element with other general plan elements or policies it has adopted) and cooperation among jurisdictions to achieve regional Greenhouse Gas (GHG) emission reduction targets and other goals set included in the Sustainable Communities Strategy (SCS) and Regional Transportation Plan (RTP). However, despite the state-level guidelines and requirements, general plan making rests with individual localities, and the content/structure of plans does vary markedly across cities. Little is known about the informational contents of these plans and their use patterns. This project reviewed the content of eight recently adopted general plans in Orange County and conducted a plan use survey and follow-up analysis of survey responses. All plans analyzed were found to convey a variety of information about their visions, goals, policies, and implementation strategies, but the plan content analysis revealed substantial variation in the way cities composed their general plans and integrated them with other plans/players. Compared to land use elements, circulation elements tended to focus more on their connections with other agencies than on internal consistency. The plan use survey yielded a low response rate which may indicate limited use of plans in the field. However, a majority of the survey responses were positive about the usefulness and usability of general plans.

Mobility of Older Adults in California: In the Era of Shared Mobility

Status

Complete

Project Timeline

January 1, 2019 - December 31, 2019

Principal Investigator

Department(s)

Civil and Environmental Engineering

Project Summary

The older adult (65 and over) population in the United States is quickly growing in proportion, and it is expected to reach its highest point by 2030 when the baby boomers will have all passed age 65. In California, the elderly population is expected to grow more than twice as fast as the total population, and this growth will vary by region. Mobility is a critical element of one’s quality of life regardless of one’s age. Good mobility and decent transportation alternatives are important in enabling the older population to participate in daily activities and remain socially active. This study will examine the transportation mobility of older adults in California by analyzing data from the 2017 National Household Travel Survey, with an emphasis on those living in rural and disadvantaged areas. Individuals aging in rural and disadvantaged communities are disproportionately affected by poverty and other challenges that accompany poor economic circumstances, and in turn, may face greater challenges than their peers aging in large urban locations. Specific objectives of this research are to estimate the impact of age, and other demographic and geographic characteristics on various measures of mobility, including ability to drive, use of shared mobility services, use of public transportation, trip frequency for both discretionary and nondiscretionary travel, unmet travel demand, barriers to using public transportation, and satisfaction with available transportation options.

Improving the Distribution of Densities in Southern California

Status

Complete

Project Timeline

January 1, 2019 - December 31, 2019

Principal Investigator

Department(s)

Urban Planning and Public Policy

Project Summary

Many of the biggest transportation challenges in Southern California arise from the lack of concentration of densities. However, little is known about how to address this critical problem and its adverse consequences. While recent years have witnessed increasing efforts to expand public transit services and encourage compact development in transit areas, there is a dearth of research providing detailed guidance for improving the distribution of densities in the region. Furthermore, existing studies have tended to focus on the City of Los Angeles, resulting in lost opportunities for understanding what challenges exist in the rest of the region, particularly in (suburban) places with great potential for density concentrations. This project will examine the complexity of urban densification dynamics with a focus on thirty selected cities in Southern California where public transit services will be widely available and thus land use intensification will be highly desired in the future. Specifically, the project will (i) conduct an exploratory analysis to identify ways in which urban densification takes place through zoning and actual land use changes that should be jointly addressed in coordination with transportation planning; (ii) develop a model to better understand how zoning has changed (in relation to the expansion of public transit services), to what extent zoning changes have led to shifts in actual land use patterns, and how changes in land use induce further zoning modifications in nearby areas; and (iii) identify hotspots that deserve attention for more strategic densification in the region.

Social Impacts of Transit Oriented Development on Disadvantaged Communities

Status

Complete

Project Timeline

January 1, 2019 - December 31, 2019

Principal Investigator

Department(s)

Urban Planning and Public Policy

Project Summary

Planners need tools to better understand the social and community impacts of transit-oriented development (TOD) so they can proactively address barriers and challenges to equitable sustainable development for low-income and disadvantaged communities. Although TOD can help achieve regional greenhouse gas (GHG) emission goals and spur local revitalization, in some cases it results in gentrification and residential displacement of long-term residents. Fear of negative TOD impacts on housing affordability, neighborhood identify, and social cohesion have driven many community groups to forcefully oppose near-station developments and planners need new approaches for integrating community perspectives into the TOD planning process.

This study surveyed residents regarding their perceptions (negative and positive) of neighborhood change and associated development along an existing commuter rail corridor and planned route of the new OC Streetcar in the City of Santa Ana, a largely low-income, Latinx community in central Orange County, California. A total of 329 surveys were collected between August and October 2019. Findings from this study include that on average residents are satisfied with neighborhood access to transport and amenities, and that higher neighborhood satisfaction was associated with a more positive assessment of development and neighborhood change. Residents living near the streetcar route had more negative assessments of change, reflecting heightened concerns about housing costs, displacement, and parking.

Accessibility, Affordability, and the Allocation of Housing Targets to California’s Local Governments

Status

Complete

Project Timeline

October 4, 2019 - October 3, 2020

Principal Investigator

Project Team

Department(s)

Urban Planning and Public Policy

Project Summary

California’s Housing Element law requires the allocation of housing targets to local governments. These targets should align with long-range regional strategies to concentrate growth in transit rich areas, but little evidence exists about the effectiveness of housing allocation schemes for achieving accessibility and affordability. Indeed, there is some evidence that – to date – the law has not served these goals effectively. In 2018 California Senate Bill (SB) 828 significantly amended the Housing Element law, conferring additional authority on the California Department of Housing & Community Development (HCD) to determine housing targets. Moreover, SB 50 (introduced in 2019) proposes to require HCD to identify “jobs-rich” areas, in which local governments would be required to allow relatively dense residential development. SB 50 proposes to also raise the minimum allowable density for residential development in areas close to transit stops. State legislators and administrators have very little information to evaluate the current housing target allocation process or its interaction with the regulatory scheme contemplated by SB 50. This project would fill that gap, providing guidance for linking housing and transportation policy. This project will provide decision support for state legislators and administrators by: 1) comparing California’s housing target allocation and implementation methods to methods currently used in other states, as well as methods described in the scholarly literature; 2) comparing the possible effects of different allocation and implementation methods on job accessibility at different levels of housing affordability; and 3) identifying ways that future legislation and implementation could promote the goals of the Housing Element law related to accessibility.