working paper

Joint Modelling of Attitudes and Behaviour in Project Evaluation: Case Study of Single-Occupant Vehicle Toll Use of Carpool Lanes in San Diego, California

Abstract

Knowing what people think about the usefulness, fairness, and success of new transport initiatives is vital information for planners and project evaluators. Methods for studying the complex relationships between attitudes and choice behaviour need to be included in evaluation processes. 

The attitudes of an individual faced with a new transport option will depend in part on whether the individual can take advantage of the new option, whether he or she actually chooses to take advantage, and the perceived benefits of the option, to the individual and to the community. Transport planners use choice models to understand factors affecting demand, but modelling of attitudes has not received similar attention. In this paper we demonstrate how a joint model of attitudes and behaviour can be used in comprehensive project evaluation. The approach involves analysing attitude survey data using a structural equations model designed for use with discrete choice and ordinal-scale variables. 

Our application involves the evaluation of responses to a project that allows solo drivers to pay a fee to use a carpool, or high-occupancy vehicle (HOV) lane facility on the Interstate 15 (1-15) Freeway in San Diego. The attitude survey is of subscribers to the program and a random sample of other freeway users. Four endogenous variables are explained as functions of each other and of exogenous variables such as income, household composition, age and gender. These endogenous variables are: (1) choice of subscription to the program, (2) mode choice of carpooling versus solo driving, (3) perception of the seriousness of the traffic congestion on the route, and (4) attitude towards allowing solo drivers to pay to save time by using the carpool lanes.

working paper

Development of a Microscopic Activity-Based Framework for Analyzing the Potential Impact of Transportation Control Measures on Vehicle Emissions

Publication Date

July 1, 1998

Abstract

The 1990 Clean Air Act Amendments (CAAA) and the Intermodal Surface Transportation Efficiency Act of 1991 (ISTEA) have defined a set of transportation control measures to counter the increase in the vehicle emissions and energy consumption due to increased travel. The value of these TCM strategies is unknown as there is limited data available to measure the travel effects of individual TCM strategies and the models are inadequate in forecasting changes in travel behavior resulting from these strategies. The work described in this paper begins to provide an operational methodology to overcome these difficulties so that the impacts of the policy mandates of both CAAA and ISTEA can be assessed. Although the framework, as currently developed, falls well short of actually forecasting changes in traveler behavior relative to policy options designed to encourage emissions reduction, the approach can be useful in estimating upper bounds of certain policy alternatives in reducing vehicle emissions. Subject to this important limitation, the potential of transportation policy options to alleviate vehicle emissions is examined in a comprehensive activity-based approach. Conclusions are drawn relative to the potential emissions savings that can be expected from efficient trip chaining behavior, ridesharing among household members, as well as from technological advances in vehicle emissions control devices represented by replacing all of the vehicles in the fleet by vehicles conforming to present-day emissions technology.

working paper

Can HOT Lanes Encourage Carpooling? A Case Study of Carpooling Behavior on the 91 Express Lanes

Abstract

This paper is a case study of carpooling behavior on the 91 Express Lanes. The 91 Express Lanes are the nation’s first implementation of High Occupancy/Toll (HOT) lanes where carpools with three or more passengers could use the lanes for free (at the time the data for this study was collected) and others pay a toll that varies by time of day to use the premium Express Lane. One concern over such a policy is that people won’t carpool if they can just pay for the travel time savings that they would normally obtain by carpooling and using a High Occupancy Vehicle (HOV) lane. Our survey data show that the rate of carpooling did not change much between the opening of the Express Lanes and now, there is a lot of changing between modes (increases and decreases in the number of passengers), there are a large number of people that carpool a few times a week, and that HOV-2s use both the regular lanes and the Express Lanes. We further investigate whether HOT lanes encourage carpooling by modeling carpool formation with discrete choice models. The results show that mode choice behavior in the corridor is similar to carpooling behavior in other locations and carpooling in the corridor is not discouraged.

working paper

Why Do People Drive to Shop? Future Travel and Telecommunications Tradeoffs

Publication Date

January 1, 1998

Abstract

In this study we look at the relationship between shopping and travel trips, especially by car, and ask whether the travel trip has intrinsic value and/or costs for shoppers.

The plan of this paper is as follows: First we establish a baseline about shopping travel, based on recent travel statistics. We then seek, through the transportation and marketing literatures, different approaches to the question of why people travel to stores. This leads us to pose specific hypotheses about shopping-related trips which we then test using activity-based demand modeling. The final sections discuss our results and conclusions. They suggest that the behaviors associated with the adoption of electronic home shopping are complex, and that it is naive to view home shopping as just another channel. Home shopping will not evolve independently of other changes in work, daily routines, and leisure time use.

working paper

Simulating Travel Reliability

Abstract

We present a simulation model designed to determine the impact on congestion of policies for dealing with travel time uncertainty. The model combines a supply side model of congestion delay with a discrete choice econometric demand model that predicts scheduling choices for morning commute trips. The supply model describes congestion technology and exogenously specifies the probability, severity, and duration of non-recurrent events. From these, given traffic volumes, a distribution of travel times is generated, from which a mean, a standard deviation, and a probability of arriving late are calculated. The demand model uses these outputs from the supply model as independent variables and choices are forecast using sample enumeration and a synthetic sample of work start times and free flow travel times. The process is iterated until a stable congestion pattern is achieved. We report on the components of expected cost and the average travel delay for selected simulations.

Phd Dissertation

The Value of Access to Highways and Light Rail Transit: Evidence for Industrial and Office Firms

Abstract

This dissertation examines the relationship between transportation access and industrial and office property rents. The primary purpose of this research is to evaluate two sparsely studied topics in the transportation-land use literature: the impacts of light rail transit on property values, and the effect of transportation facilities on non-residential land uses.

Multivariate regression analysis is used on longitudinal data for approximately five hundred and twenty office properties and five hundred industrial properties collected from the San Diego metropolitan region over the period from 1986 to 1995. Asking rents ($/square foot/month) is the dependent variable. Straight-line distance of each property to the nearest freeway on/off ramp, the nearest light rail station, and to the San Diego central business district provide measures of access. Other independent variables include building and neighborhood characteristics.

The findings show that access to freeways is consistently significant in predicting office rents. This result indicates that freeways are important in shaping office property values, and by extension office land use patterns. Light rail transit did not have a significant effect on office rents. Access to the CBD was only significant for downtown office properties. The CBD variable in this case may be a proxy for the effect of localization economies. None of the measures of access was significant for industrial properties.

This research underscores the importance of refining measures of access in order to capture and better understand the transportation-land use relationship. In particular, if the distance of an industrial firm to freeways, light rail transit, and the CBD is not important, then what kinds of access do matter? This research also has important implications for planning light rail transit systems. There is strong evidence that light rail systems do not provide enough travel cost savings to increase non-residential property values. This finding should be taken seriously in planning alignments for future light rail systems. Light rail systems need to be aligned with existing activity centers, rather than expected to stimulate new development or the redevelopment of distressed urban areas.

working paper

A Simultaneous Model of Activity Participation and Trip Chain Generation by Households

Publication Date

July 1, 1997

Author(s)

Abstract

A trip generation model has been developed using a time-use perspective, in which trips are generated in conjunction with out-of-home activities, and time spent traveling is another component of overall time use. The model jointly forecasts three sets of endogenous variables – (1) activity participation and (2) travel time (together making up total out-of home time use), and (3) trip generation — as a function of household characteristics and accessibility indices. It is estimated with data from the Portland, Oregon 1994 Activity and Travel Survey. Results show that the basic model, which has ten endogenous time use and trip generation variables and thirteen exogenous variables, fits well, and all postulated relationships are upheld. Test show that the basic model, which divides activities into work and nonwork, can be extended to a three-way breakdown of subsistence, discretionary and obligatory activities. The model can also capture the effects of in-home work on trip chaining and activity participation. We use the model to explore the effects on time use and trip chaining of GIS-based and zone-based accessibility indices.

policy brief

Transportation Plans: Their Informational Content and Use Patterns in Southern California