Phd Dissertation

Modeling and Management of Emerging Mobility Systems: Based on vehicle and trip flow dynamics in absolute and relative spaces

Publication Date

May 2, 2022

Author(s)

Abstract

Traffic congestion is known to have many negative impacts both for travelers and society as a whole (e.g., emissions, noise). This dissertation focuses on the model development and analysis of vehicle and trip flow dynamics. Several transportation systems are considered, from a single bottleneck to a network region, in order to propose effective management strategies to reduce traffic congestion. Since different transportation systems are considered, different models and space paradigms are needed to model each system’s dynamics. At the local level, it is reasonable to study the traffic flow in the physical road and how it evolves spatially and temporally with traditional traffic flow theory models. In contrast, when the network is highly complex (e.g., corridors with many on- and off-ramps or urban cores), it is reasonable to disregard the detailed vehicle-network interaction at the distinct physical locations and model traffic dynamics with more aggregated models in the relative space. The relative space differs from the traditional absolute space because the former is defined relative to individual trips’ destinations, and the trajectories of different trips in the network but with different origins and destinations can be studied together in the same (relative) space-time domain.

When queues start to build up at local freeway bottlenecks, the capacity drop (CD) phenomenon reduces the maximum flow that the bottleneck can accommodate. First, the heterogeneity of vehicles’ driving parameters is studied for such local transportation systems. On the management side, some researchers propose to use Variable Speed Limit control (VSL) to prevent the CD. However, the necessary acceleration length between the end of the control application area and the bottleneck has not been analyzed thoroughly. By developing an effective open-loop control, I present an analytical formulation to determine the minimum acceleration stretch required to prevent the CD.

The so-called “bathtub model” captures the inflow, outflow, and the instantaneous number of active vehicles in the network by assuming: (i) that the network can be treated as an undifferentiated unit where vehicles travel in a relative space towards their own destination, and (ii) that there is a network-level speed-density relationship for all vehicle trips. This bathtub model and the relative space perspective are attractive to model complex network systems. However, most studies disregard the role that demand plays in such a system. The trip distance distribution (TDD) is part of the bathtub model and is not well understood. In this dissertation, empirical data from Chicago is used to show that most of the existing assumptions on TDD do not hold. Further, I propose to study the trip flow dynamics by developing a probabilistic agent-based bathtub model, i.e., a microscopic simulation model in the relative space, to track the completion rate of trips and trip duration of individuals, given any TDD. Then, the bathtub model is used to study the corridor level dynamics and propose a dynamic distance-based high occupancy toll lane pricing scheme. Further, several fleet sizing strategies of shared mobility systems are explored. To do so, a compartmental model for trip flow dynamics is proposed, where trips can be waiting for a shared vehicle to pick them up (point queue model) or traveling in the network (bathtub model).

In summary, this dissertation presents a comprehensive review of two modeling paradigms where space is treated differently. It explores particular management strategies leveraging the most suitable modeling paradigm to improve traffic congestion. In this dissertation, the traffic dynamics of different transportation systems are studied by integrating first-principles analysis, data-driven methods, and simulation-based studies. This dissertation lays a good foundation for future studies on emerging mobility systems.

policy brief

Public Transportation, Transportation Network Companies (TNCs), and Active Modes

Phd Dissertation

Transportation Noise Impacts on Residential Property Values in Los Angeles County: A Spatial Hedonic Analysis

Publication Date

March 7, 2022

Author(s)

Abstract

As population densities in urban areas increase, the associated demand on transportation infrastructure continues to exacerbate impacts on surrounding communities. These demands create a number of socioeconomic burdens including housing price impacts when communities are regularly exposed to excessive noise levels. Although noise impacts are not as commonly recognized or assessed in comparison to other environmental issues such as air, ground, or water pollution, it has been well documented in the literature that a wide range of health issues exist when communities are exposed to noise from transportation infrastructure. From a research perspective, the correlation of these health issues to the presence of impactful noise is difficult to quantify, as noise is subjective and requires translation into varying degrees of annoyance to deem it as detrimental from both health and economic perspectives. This dissertation utilizes spatial hedonic price (HP) models to estimate individuals’ marginal willingness-to-pay (MWTP) to reside in noise-impacted areas. These MWTP values can then be used to both valuate economic impacts and as a noise annoyance level proxy to identify zones that are at-risk due to excessive transportation noise exposure. The first analysis in this dissertation reviews salient transportation noise-related papers that have been published since Navrud’s comprehensive 2002 transportation noise literature review. In a review of recent literature, this dissertation found that transportation noise research has evolved to include advanced Geographic Information System data, and leverages increasingly powerful processors and statistical analysis programs. In addition, although significant transportation noise research has been conducted in Europe following EU Environmental Noise Directive 2002/49/EC, a relatively minimal number of studies have been conducted in the United States — especially in Southern California, revealing a research gap that this dissertation helps to address. The second analysis investigates the impacts of aircraft operations around Los Angeles International Airport. Using a subset of 2010-2014 single-family home sales data from the Los Angeles County Office of the Assessor (LACOA), HP spatial autoregressive models with autoregressive disturbances (SARAR) were estimated. The study hypothesizes and confirms that a negative impact value would be observed for homes being located within noise-mapped zones around the airport, along with an improvement in estimation values compared to previous fixed spatial effects ordinary least squares techniques. The third analysis in this dissertation investigates two important topics. First, it hypothesizes negative home value impacts from nearby freight rail operations in the densely populated South Bay region of Los Angeles County. Noise from freight rail lines is analyzed using an HP SARAR model and confirm negative valuation impacts to homes located near these rail lines. Second, it hypothesizes that by using a subset of the master LACOA dataset above, varying levels of spatial homogeneity can be comparatively analyzed between two samples that use similar data and modeling techniques. Results indicate that when neighboring zones have distinct differences in jurisdiction, fixed spatial effect delineations remain statistically significant. However, when neighboring zones have similar jurisdictional or demographic characteristics, spatial model parameters are able to account for fixed delineations.

Phd Dissertation

The Impact of E-shopping on Household Travel in the Age of the Pandemic

Abstract

During the past two to three decades, and especially during the Covid-19 pandemic, e-shopping has become increasingly popular, changing the way people shop and travel. With increasing concerns about the environmental impacts of transportation, particularly on regional air quality and on emissions of greenhouse gases (GHG), it is important to understand how e-shopping has affected household travel behavior.In this dissertation, I investigated the influence of e-shopping before, during, and after the pandemic by analyzing data from the 2009 and the 2017 U.S. National Household Travel Surveys (NHTS), from the 2017 American Time Use Survey (ATUS), and from an IPSOS survey of Californians conducted in late May 2021. Understanding changes in shopping is essential to business owners, logistics managers (for adapting supply chains), transportation planners (for mitigating the impacts of warehousing and of additional residential freight deliveries), and policymakers (for helping at-risk and underserved groups). This dissertation has three parts. In the first part, I estimated zero-inflated negative binomial models to analyze factors that affected residential deliveries before the pandemic based on the 2009 and 2017 NHTS. I found that e-shoppers in the U.S. were more varied in 2017 than in 2009. Households with more females, higher incomes, and more education, received more deliveries. I also analyzed the 2017 ATUS to explore factors that influence grocery shopping. I found that in-store grocery shoppers were more likely to be female and unemployed but less likely to be younger, to have less than a college education, and to be African American. In contrast, online grocery shoppers were more likely to be female. In the second part, I studied the impact of e-shopping on household travel using propensity score matching. My analysis of 2017 NHTS data showed that before the pandemic, greater online shopping was associated with more frequent trips and slightly more travel. Furthermore, the extent to which an increase in the number of activities translated into more travel depends on population density, the day of the week, the frequency of online shopping, and the type of activity. In the third part, I analyzed the impact of the Covid-19 pandemic on grocery shopping frequency in-store, and online with home delivery (e-grocery) or pickup (click-and-pick), to understand how they changed due to the pandemic, and how they may change after, using ordered models and structural equation models. My results showed that Californians kept shopping for groceries in brick-and-mortar stores during the pandemic but less frequently than before. The pandemic accelerated the adoption of e-grocery and click-and-pick with some strong generation effects: younger generations were more likely to experiment with e-grocery and click-and-pick, while older generations relied more on in-store shopping. Education also made a difference, but thankfully race did not impact the use of e-grocery and click-and-pick, and intentions to use e-grocery and click-and-pick (but it did affect in-store grocery shopping before). My results also illustrated the heterogeneity of Hispanics. As expected, tech-savvy households were much more likely to embrace e-grocery and click-and-pick.

Phd Dissertation

Modeling and Analysis of a Mobility Portfolio Framework for Shared- Autonomous Transportation Systems

Publication Date

February 9, 2022

Author(s)

Abstract

The emerging and rapidly changing landscape of autonomous vehicles and shared mobility technologies bring up possibilities for a paradigm shift in how we model and analyze mobility. Transportation and mobility systems can now be connected continuously and seamlessly, which can make them more flexible and shareable. What can make this possible? Put simply, it would require integrating various mobility options so that travelers can freely hop among them. The demarcation lines among modes can then become increasingly hazy, as every individual trip may include multiple modes to various degrees. This implies that the paradigm shift is in how we view the travel modes. What were traditionally considered as limited discrete mode options, need to be seen as part of a continuum. In turn, we should focus more on mode combinations rather than individual travel modes. In this dissertation, we propose shifting the focus to the new idea of a mode option pool with an associated structure. The option pool would include every type of travel option in a continuous spectrum. This observation motivates the phrase ‘travel-option chain (TOC)’ mode proposed in this dissertation as a combination of travel options in a continuous spectrum. Shared use of vehicles – either time-shared, or seat-shared – expands the travel option pool. Autonomous vehicle technology makes even more time-shared use of vehicles possible, as the driver constraint is also removed, and thus further expands the travel mode option pool. Then the question is on how to make such a larger option pool available for a large number of users, to improve their level of mobility and the productivity of the vehicles as well as the associated infrastructure. One aspect that needs to be addressed is that people cannot be individually owning the vehicles and infrastructure involved in all of the mobility options they use from the pool. Different people may partially or fully own different components such as, for instance, vehicles or spaces where they are parked. Some ownership may be time-shared as well. Publicly provided transit systems with purchased tickets will naturally be part of many TOC modes. Subscription-type ownership is a possibility, if mobility service providers offer the options for purchase, and they can be bundled options as well, similar to phone plans. This fits within Mobility-as-a-Service (MaaS) platforms that have been proposed in recent years. In this dissertation, a powerful user-side concept, ‘mobility portfolios’ is proposed that encompasses MaaS platforms, subscriptions, ownership, bundled plans and selection of optimal TOCs from a continuum spectrum of modes. The question then ensues on how we can find the optimal TOC modes. From an analytical standpoint, this can be solved with a ridematching problem formulation of matching paths in a time-expanded multimodal network. A more vexing problem is how people can travel on these TOC modes unless they have paid for it in a certain way. The mobility portfolio scheme proposed in this dissertation is geared to make it possible for them to pay for it in an efficient way and in a shareable manner with enough flexibility. This dissertation defines mobility portfolio as a “grouping of the number of hours/cost/resources that can be spent on each distinct travel options, so as to fit within a time/cost/resource constraint specified for a given time period”. The portfolio approach compartmentalizes the travel options that are chained, and allocates appropriate “quantities” of them, when we view them as consumable travel commodities and resources. The portfolio scheme incorporates pricing for the commodities and are expected to bring in efficiency and cost savings while increasing shared mobility participation. This is a good approach for controlling TOC mode change travel behaviors and it subsumes currently envisaged ideas such as MaaS mobility bundles in a smart and shared mobility system with subscription options. The focus of this dissertation is on the user level decisions on selecting the TOC modes from their mobility portfolios scheme. Innovative options such as users offering their own resources (e.g., owned vehicles) and their own services (e.g., potential driving for shared rides) are incorporated in the portfolios. We develop an iterative framework which is rooted on a learning-based travel cost perception update model, so as to model the users being provided with the best travel options as well as the best usage plan for mobility portfolios. Performing simulated case studies on a real network, we confirm that the proposed framework converges to the optimum mobility portfolio state for system participants and improves the performance of the system by inducing people to use shared mobility options more.

published journal article

Factors influencing alternative fuel adoption decisions in heavy-duty vehicle fleets

Abstract

Understanding heavy-duty vehicle (HDV) fleet operator behavior with respect to the adoption of alternative fuel vehicles (AFVs) is critically important for accelerating the diffusion of these technologies, and for achieving societal benefits through reduced emissions and improved public health. However, fleet operator perspectives have thus far received limited attention, leaving a key knowledge gap. This study aims to fill this gap by exploring HDV fleet operator decisions about alternative fuel adoption using both existing literature and new empirical data. To this end, we first develop an initial theoretical framework of AFV fleet adoption behavior in organizations based on existing theories and literature. We then empirically improve the framework by investigating 20 organizations in California via in-depth qualitative interviews and project reports. A total of 29 adoptions and 42 non-adoption cases were probed across various alternative fuel technologies, including natural gas, propane, electricity, hydrogen, biodiesel, and renewable diesel options. Content analysis of the qualitative data yielded 38 motivators or barriers related to AFV adoption, encompassing perceived technological characteristics, organization characteristics, and external environmental influences. The study results contribute theoretically and empirically to a better understanding of the demand-side aspects of AFV adoption by HDV fleet operators, particularly in California and in the other US states that follow California’s environmental policies.

research report

Evaluating Mixed Electric Vehicle and Conventional Fueled Vehicle Fleets for Lastmile Package Delivery

research report

Public Transportation, Transportation Network Companies (TNCs), and Active Modes

published journal article

An L.A. story: The impact of housing costs on commuting

Abstract

The empirical impact of housing costs on commuting is still relatively poorly understood. This impact is especially salient in California given the state’s notoriously high housing costs, which have forced many lower- and middle-class households to move inland in search of affordable housing at the cost of longer commutes. To investigate this linkage, we relied on Generalized Structural Equation Modeling and analyzed 2012 CHTS data for Los Angeles County – the most populous county in the U.S. Our model, which jointly explains commuting distance and time, accounts for residential self-selection and car use endogeneity, while controlling for household characteristics and land use around residences and workplaces. We find that households who can afford more expensive neighborhoods have shorter commute distances (−2.3% and − 3.1% per additional $100 k to median home values around workplaces and residences respectively). Job density, distance to the CBD, and land-use diversity around workplaces have a relatively greater impact on commuting than the corresponding variables around commuters’ residences. Compared to non-Hispanics, Hispanic workers commute longer distances (+3.5%), and so do African American (+5.1%) and Asian (+2.0%) workers compared to Caucasians, while college educated workers have shorter (−2.6% to −3.6%) commutes. Furthermore, commuters in the top income brackets tend to have faster commutes than lower income workers. Finally, women’s commutes are ~41% shorter than men’s, possibly because they are balancing work with domestic responsibilities. Better understanding the determinants of commuting is critical to inform housing and transportation policy, improve the health of commuters, reduce air pollution, and achieve climate goals.

research report

Impacts of connected and autonomous vehicles on the performance of signalized networks: A network fundamental diagram approach